Need mini pies? Check out our pie menu. We can make any pie into mini versions, $60/dozen. Perfect for any wedding or shower favor.

1 dozen minimum requirement for ordering

Chocolate Covered Strawberries $3/each

Lemon Squares $36/dozen

made with hand pressed lemon juice and poured over our homemade shortbread crust

Blueberry Lemon Squares $42/dozen

muddled blueberries mixed into our traditional lemon mixture and baked on a graham cracker crust

Chocolate Overload cake squares $60/dozen

chocolate cake served with chocolate gnash and frosting

Jumbo Whoopie Pies with buttercream frosting $42/dozen

softball sized shells served with an ice cream scoop sized portion of buttercream frosting. Best enjoyed at room temp

small Whoopie Pies with buttercream frosting $33/dozen

the more responsible sized whoopie for the less adventurous dessert lover

Cheesecake Cookie Bars $42/dozen

We smashed our most popular pie with our most popular cookie. This chocolate chip cookie crust layer is topped with our delicious classic cheesecake and served with more bits of cookie on top

Brownies $42/dozen

Homemade chocolate brownies, a classic without the box

Chocolate Chip Cookies $36/dozen

traditional chocolate chip cookies that take 2 hands to hold and eat

Peanut Butter Cookies $36/dozen

large PB classics with crystal sugar and the traditional fork marks for authenticity

Brian Cookies $42/dozen

Named after our beloved brother, he was a huge fan of our sugar cookies, and obsessed with rainbow sprinkles. Coated on both sides of course. These cookies are a little more expensive because the entire cost per dozen is donated to renovate the Brian Eldredge Memorial Skatepark in Amesbury, MA.

3” Fruit Tarts $42/dozen

Adorable fruit tarts made in mini sweet short bread shells, homemade vanilla pudding, topped with fresh seasonal fruits and coated with an apricot wash to preserve that amazing fresh fruit from browning

Brownie Pudding Cups $78/dozen

Customer favorite dessert for sure. Our homemade chocolate pudding (never skip the coffee) is layered with our brownie chunks, and homemade whipped cream. Served in a 16oz plastic cup with a lid! Because it can easily feed 2 people. Inquiry about speciality decorative serving containers

Mini brownie pudding cups $54/dozen

eat responsibly

Cider Hill Donut pudding cups $85/dozen

Our hometown roots made it over the boarder! Enjoy our classic vanilla pudding, cut up cider hill donuts, and layers of homemade whipped cream. Only available during Cider Hill’s season 16oz plastic cup

Mini Cider Hill pudding cups $61/dozen

yum. on a smaller level

Want individual pies for your event? Check out our PIE list and contact us for pricing for individual serving prices

Need an assorted dessert box with samples of our most popular items? Try these tiered options

$3/pp

plain/chocolate dipped cannolis, mini lemon squares, and brownie bites

$5/pp

plain/chocolate dipped cannolis, mini lemon squares, brownie bites, chocolate cake, and cheesecake cookie bars

$7.50/pp

plain/chocolate dipped cannolis, mini lemon squares, brownie bites, chocolate cake, cheesecake cookie bars, fruit tarts, and mini whoopie pies

$10/pp

plain/chocolate dipped cannoli’s, mini lemon squares, brownie bites, chocolate cake, cheesecake cookie bars, fruit tarts, mini whoopie pies, and chocolate covered strawberries.

gluten free options include..

Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake Squares, brownies, cheesecake cookie bars, and all cookie types, Inquire for pricing